Salaam, Shalom, Peace!
My sympathies are with ordinary Palestinians and Israelis who are caught up in the present mess. In the past I have disagreed with many actions taken by the Israeli government regarding the Palestinian people. However, I have to admit the present situation is a direct result of the actions of Hamas. While the religion of Islam allows one the right to defend oneself, one’s family and one’s country, Islam absolutely forbids attacking ordinary civilians – especially women and children. Though the air strikes by Israel will unfortunately result in some civilian casualties, at least they’re not deliberately attacking civilians…
Many people downplay the rocket attacks by Hamas. Even when there was supposedly a ceasefire between Israel and Palestinians, Hamas was firing rockets into Israel. Though only small and usually few, this was done on a regular basis. In total, hundreds or thousands of rockets were fired each year! Hamas sees every Israeli as a legitimate target! Each time, they were firing into civilian towns and villages close to the border with Gaza – not military targets. Hamas are breaking a very clear Islamic prohibition not to attack civilians! Even Hamas has openly stated many times, they do not recognise the State of Israel’s right to exist and we all know they would change that if it was within their power to do so… How can Israel deal with them when they behave in this fashion?
If Israel were any other country, they would also take military action against a neighbouring state or territory, that was firing rockets into their country, killing and wounding their citizens. While I do not like the situation in Gaza, I do not like the way Israel has often treated Palestinians, I can’t blame them for their recent actions towards Gaza. How can I support Hamas? They have been bad news for Palestinians even before, but especially since they came to power in Gaza. I strongly urge my fellow Muslim bothers and sisters, to think carefully how we can best serve the interests of ordinary Palestinians and not to believe the current propaganda trying to get us all to back Hamas. If it weren’t for Hamas’ rockets, would Israel be bombing Gaza now? If it wasn’t for their intolerance of Israel, wouldn’t the peace process have progressed further? These are important questions for us to consider. As Muslims we most certainly must look out for our brothers and sisters of faith around the world, but most importantly, we must do what is right! Should we support other Muslims if what they’re doing is not right? Surely we will be questioned!
The fact is Israel exists, whether we like it or not! Many Israelis have fought and died for their country over the past 60 years. The original Palestine no longer exists. Today Palestinians are a stateless people, this is truly a tragedy for them and my heart goes out to them. Any solution to their plight must take into account Israel’s existence and the present reality. Many Israelis are the third or four generation born in that land, they live in a functioning state.
Palestinians and Israelis must learn to come to terms with their present situation. If they both want to live in peace and security, they need to accept and eventually learn to love one another. They need to learn what we all need to learn. We all live together on the surface of one planet, we are all brothers and sisters. We need to share this planet and want for others what we desire for ourselves. Only when we accept this and learn to change accordingly will we find true peace, happiness and security! We will never attain this through bombs and incessant warfare, but only through changing ourselves!
Paul Salahuddin Armstrong
May we have your permission to reprint your comments “Hamas and Israel” at http://jewishinfonews.wordpress.com
Sure, you can reprint the post “Hamas and Israel” as long as it is credited and you post a link to our blog https://wulfrunasufi.wordpress.com/.
With regards to some feedback I have received, I’d just like to make the following statement:
I do not mean to downplay the seriousness of what is happening or the tragedy of it. But how many women and children have Hamas deliberately targeted in Israel? All children are innocent and should be entitled to a good start in life, no matter whether Palestinian or Israeli. If Hamas wasn’t providing Israel an excuse to attack Gaza, over 300 Palestinians would still be alive today and Gaza wouldn’t be in ruins!
I agree Israel has on numerous occasions been responsible for atrocities themselves. I am not defending Israel, but I cannot defend Hamas either. As a Muslim I cannot support anyone who is in the wrong. I want peace in Palestine, for Palestinians to enjoy a good quality of life, not to be living in oppression or in fear for their lives. However I do not believe Hamas will be the bringers of such peace. Their strategy is only making the situation more terrible for Palestinians.
Thanks for speaking out in your article. I’ve found that most Sufi’s have a biased view against Israel, Judaism and Jews. They neglect to see the bigger, historical picture and facts on the ground such as you have presented. Israel, Judaism and Jews are pluralistic and democratic as a basis of Jewish philosophy. Many non-Jewish people live and thrive in Israel. Mosques and churches of every denomination are everywhere in Israel and are protected. Would Jews be welcomed and protected in a Palestine under Abbas, Hamas or any other Pal leader to live and raise Jewish children? Or any other Muslim country at this point in time? The truth is revealing.